By Arré Bench Nov. 27, 2020
On its homepage, Tooter proudly declares itself to be “Made in India”, and greets visitors with a message that proclaims “Welcome to Swadeshi Andolan 2.0”. But for all the bluster, Tooter itself appears to be little more than a clone of a clone – the idea behind Tooter was directly lifted from already existing Twitter alternatives like Parler and Gab.
Indian Twitter had a field day earlier this week when they collectively stumbled upon Tooter, a “swadeshi” alternative to the massively popular social media platform. On its homepage, Tooter proudly declares itself to be “Made in India”, and greets visitors with a message that proclaims “Welcome to Swadeshi Andolan 2.0”. But for all the bluster that greets you when you visit the homepage, Tooter itself appears to be little more than a clone of a clone – that is, the idea behind Tooter was directly lifted from already existing Twitter alternatives like Parler and Gab. And calling it a clone is more than just a figure of speech, because many users reported, Tooter was literally cloning the application programming interface (API) of Gab on its backend.
Desi tooter is not so desi after all, it has been created by free code available on github called gab. Gab is a social media website like twitter & they made this code & released to opensource
In short desi tooter andolan was created from a code made by an American. pic.twitter.com/EL7EhyUsIG
— Abby (@india_abby) November 24, 2020
Holy shit, Tooter is just rehosting Gab, which in turn is a fork of Mastodon, an open-source social networking platform (built by a German software developer, which is, in fact, NOT Swadeshi). All they have done is replace Gab with Tooter, and added some more nonsensical blubs. pic.twitter.com/GECpNoEUIz
— Vib (@vibhavp01) November 24, 2020
Pratik Sinha, the editor of fact-checking platform AltNews also shared similar findings. He also highlighted how Gab had quickly become a haven for extremist speech and conservative propaganda for its users in the United States, suggesting that Tooter could also follow a similar trajectory in India.
What is tooter from a technological stand point? Tooter has adopted the codebase of GAB, a social media initiative by US based neo-nazis. GAB was originally forked from Mastodon, which is open source.
What is GAB? Some perspective here:https://t.co/TrrGIhRXye
— Pratik Sinha (@free_thinker) November 24, 2020
After becoming the butt of many jokes and memes on Twitter, this latest challenge to Tooter’s “swadeshi” branding is sure to invite another round of mockery. For starters, one needs either a Gmail or Yahoo ID to even sign up to the platform, neither of which are Indian companies. Secondly, the visual aesthetic, down to the logo’s outline, seems to closely mimic Twitter, a platform to which it claims to be an alternative. And now, with even its backend coding being lifted from another foreign company, it seems the platform giving itself the “swadeshi” tag is just a case of wishful thinking.
On Tooter, if you click "quote", you get this. Didn't even change the name 😅 pic.twitter.com/BsMnplLghF
— Ramanan (@Ramanan_V) November 24, 2020
Much like TikTok alternatives Chingari and Mitron, and WhatsApp alternatives Kimbho and Bolo, it appears that Tooter will follow the cycle of proudly announcing its arrival, being exposed as inferior, and meekly fading away into irrelevance.